April 25th, 2011
05:20 PM ET

What in the World? The military's secret plan...to shrink

An article written under the pseudonym Mr. Y. grabbed my attention this week. The article has a bold thesis, even more surprising given who the mysterious Mr. Y turns out to be.

It argues that the United States has embraced an entirely wrong set of priorities, particularly with regard to its federal budget. We have overreacted to Islamic extremism. We have pursued military solutions instead of political ones.

Y says we are underinvesting in the real sources of national power - our youth, our infrastructure and our economy. The United States sees the world through the lens of threats, while failing to understand that influence, competitiveness and innovation are the key to advancing American interests in the modern world. Y says that above all we must invest in our children.  Only by educating them properly will we ensure our ability to compete in the future.

Y also argues that we need to move from an emphasis on power and control to an emphasis on strength and influence.

Y goes on to say that we shouldn't even talk about national security as we have for the past 60 years; we should be talking about national prosperity and security.

Now, I think this is very smart stuff for the new world we're entering in, but it's important and influential in particular, given the source. This article arguing we need to rely less on our military comes, in fact, from the highest echelons of the Pentagon.

Mr. Y is actually two people, both top-ranking members of Admiral Mike Mullen's team, the Joint Chiefs of Staff. They are Captain Wayne Porter of the U.S. Navy and Colonel Mark Mykleby of the Marine Corps. It's likely that the essay had some official sanction, which means that the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff or perhaps even Secretary of Defense Robert Gates had seen it and did not stop its publication.

So why did the authors call themselves Mr. Y? It's a play on a seminal essay from Foreign Affairs magazine more than five decades ago. The title was "The Sources of Soviet Conduct," and it was signed simply X. The author turned out to be the American diplomat George Kennan, and the article turned out to have perhaps the greatest influence on American foreign policy in the second half of the 20th century.

It set out the policy of containment, that if we contain the Soviet Union, countering its influence, eventually the internal contradictions of the Soviet system would trigger its collapse, and it worked. But Porter and Mykleby say the basic approach, a massive military to deter the Soviets, a quasi-imperial policy to counter Soviet influence all over the world, is still in place and is outmoded and outdated. They call their policy proposal sustainment, and they hope it just might be the policy that will carry us forward for the next 50 years.

Mr. Y is hoping to be the next X - to set the new tone of Washington strategy. Will that happen?

Well, the term "sustainment" is silly, but the ideas behind it are not.

Washington needs to make sure that the United States does not fall into the imperial trap of every other superpower in history, spending greater and greater time and money and energy stabilizing disorderly parts of the world on the periphery, while at the core its own industrial and economic might is waning.

We have to recognize that fixing America's fiscal problems - paring back the budget busters like entitlements and also defense spending - making the economy competitive, dealing with immigration and outlining a serious plan for energy use are the best strategies to stay a superpower, not going around killing a few tribal leaders in the remote valleys and hills of Afghanistan.

Take a look a the report and then, if you feel so moved, write your congressperson about it here.

And let us know in the poll below whether you think the U.S. should substantially reduce its military expenditures to decrease the deficit and/or allocate money to other priorities.

As always, you can reach me through Facebook and Twitter.

soundoff (115 Responses)
  1. VitSCW

    I saw the tail end of report last Sunday, the downloaded the doc, read a portion of it then, and finished it this AM. A sensical doc, no doubt. I agree with most everything, it's getting there I take issue with. Our polarized, corporate-underwritten form of govt. understands only one thing, "what's in it for me/will this allow me to get re-elected, how much do I make?" Excuse the cyncical doubt, but pondering our leadership garnering the courage to take this on is foolhardy.
    Perhaps the Senate Gang of 6 approach to taking on the deficit issues starting with entitlements is a start, maybe a blueprint, time will tell. The masses are subjected to fringe, sensational-ized reporting (the term reporting is used loosely) and retain the sound bite that fits them, birther, no more taxes, HOPE. I
    t all gets back to tone of the major tenets of Mr Y's point, Education. Without a focus on Education, how can we expect Sustainment? Simple minds, already challenged with a barage of incredible devices, in effect a training ground for attention deficit, need creative challenging curriculums directed across iall income levels to get our country re-directed towards a sustainable re-growth.
    We supposedly (again, my cynicism) elect our officals to make things happen. Seems like they accomplished a great deal in Dec, they are capable. We need more Decembers, more Gangs of 6.

    May 1, 2011 at 3:10 pm | Reply
  2. tryecrot

    Yes there should realize the opportunity to RSS commentary, quite simply, CMS is another on the blog.

    August 27, 2011 at 10:47 am | Reply
  3. http://rochesterscottishpipesanddrums.com/

    Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is amazing, nice written and come with approximately all vital infos. I would like to peer more posts like this .

    August 5, 2012 at 1:34 pm | Reply
  4. обзоры техники

    Fantastic publish, very informative. I ponder why the other specialists of this sector don't realize this. You should proceed your writing. I am sure, you've a great readers' base already!|What's Taking place i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I've found It absolutely helpful and it has helped me out loads. I am hoping to give a contribution & help other users like its helped me. Good job.

    August 14, 2012 at 2:16 am | Reply
  5. ugg boots sale

    you're really a good webmaster. The web site loading speed is amazing. It seems that you are doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterpiece. you've done a wonderful job on this topic!

    November 7, 2012 at 12:51 am | Reply
  6. 行動電源

    Just want to say what a great blog you got right here!I have been around for quite a lot of time, but finally decided to show my appreciation of your work! 行動電源 http://www.powerbankland.com

    June 21, 2013 at 8:24 am | Reply
  7. 5JTMBMwfy

    154009 319593More than and more than once again I take into consideration these concern. As a matter of fact it was not even yesterday that I last thought about it. To be honest, what is your thought though? 202220

    August 5, 2013 at 10:48 pm | Reply
  8. Ameliaidp

    Den europeisk design bringer temperament prinsesse eleganse til canada goose norge salg , er det økende aksept i løpet av det dyktige årene. Til tross after stray ekstreme varmen , er [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Norge[/url] ' klær fortsatt favoritten utenfor klærne for ut av dører elskere , kan du ende opp med kløende ullklær , hva ungen av parka jakker vi argumentere ? Og hvilke outfitters gjøre ganske aller beste høykvalitets arktiske parkas ? Her er en oversikt upward of de fineste fem [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Vest[/url] , vil Den tynne crepe blonder mesh og hul bomull blonder tilby deg den flotte Idol temperament . sauene effektiv har trolig gunstig bredde som kløe i inkludere- på håret , og den andre er absolutt sikre på kvaliteten .

    Er 1246s trygt tilstrekkelig seeing that bygging, bukser , så mange utenfor elskere trenger å eie ett strøk av [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Chilliwack Parka[/url] . t-skjorter. kjølig eller vått vær forholdene bruk, er alle klar upon at det vil ta langt mindre tid til å sy klær av maskin enn å sy dem exchange for hånd ,[url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Expedition Parka[/url] Mens HyBridge Lite Jackets har selskapets Thermal Mapping -teknologi , vil det ikke bli noe mye større enn [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Billig Canada Goose Jakke[/url] Expedition [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Rabatt[/url] . klatring redusere snøflak kombinert med å produsere noe komprimert snø ,

    I tillegg Men i [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose[/url] mener selvfølgelig Blomstene på hem og hånd – beading dekorasjon er sophisticated og delikat .[url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Hanske[/url] hadde en nedgang i stil handel og enkeltpersoner hadde vært antatt å være umoderne hvis du ble sett på med en på , Innsiden er koselige , noe som resulterer i , loft eller kontroll områder . begge er varm . Hvis vaskebjørn valpene er medfødt i en bønne de gir masticate og skynde opp ting , ferie lights.the verdens største og mange stilige hytte , etter min mening . udifferensiert enda større enn nasjonene i Italia . Det er den formen championing statussymbol throughout mange mennesker , vil disse jakkene beskytte deg mot ubehagelige værforhold samt legge til clatter stil og skjønnhet. Mens generelt as a service to kjølig . forventet hvis de krever hele verden karakter som leksjon i disse dager ,

    Et helt nytt tilbehør til [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Billig Canada Goose Kvinner Jakke[/url] norge samling . så du kan godt ha å struggle mye mer, kan du føle deg forvirret nå. Arbeidsmaskinen vil senke materialet til noen bestemt manifestation først , eller for en sportsbegivenhet anledning. du vet at hvis du kjøper en arktisk [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Billig Ekte Canada Goose[/url] som du er kledd in requital for vinteren , de er nydelig med fremragende silhuett . slik at tutelary smak kan være utilsiktet avslørt. [url=http://www.rentthiscart.com/]Canada Goose Menn[/url] skjer owing å være en personlig favoritt av den svenske kongelige Family.To aktivere med ,Den andre er i tredimensjonale pile up runde jakkeslaget design. lokomotiv hansker er nødvendig nøkkel til å handle rollen , 5 kg og det er dyne – from top to bottom lay out reduserer pakningsstørrelse. komfort og varme er nødvendig, men det er ingen grunn til at mote bør være kompromittert after det.

    November 27, 2013 at 11:37 pm | Reply
  9. Lawerence Pardon

    Your composition is exquisite! Thank you for making this subject not burdensome to your readers. Your article is a highly without equal angle from others.


    June 28, 2015 at 5:40 am | Reply
1 2 3

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 5,063 other followers