Why Anthony Weiner should not resign
June 13th, 2011
10:46 AM ET

Why Anthony Weiner should not resign

Editor's Note: Anne-Marie Slaughter is the Bert G. Kerstetter ’66 University Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University. Follow her on Twitter at @slaughteram.

By Anne-Marie Slaughter – Special to CNN

Whenever I give a speech, someone in the audience is likely to come up afterwards and suggest that I run for office. I am flattered, but my response is always the same. If I lived in a country like Britain, where election campaigns are time-limited and publicly funded, I would certainly consider running for office, at least after my children have left home.

But in the American political system I could not imagine putting myself or my family through the endless fundraising, with its attendant focus on rich lobbyists and investors rather than actual constituents, and the relentless media and partisan scrutiny. The price exacted is simply too high, particularly when it is possible to serve in appointed office instead.

I am hardly alone in that calculation. Indeed, in my experience the willingness to run for office is increasingly rare among many of the people whom I would most like to see in Congress or state and local government.

They have to be willing to give themselves up to the public – media included – 24 hours a day, while typically earning only a small fraction of what they could earn in the private sector and accepting the continual frustration of operating in a political and bureaucratic system in which it is harder and harder to get anything good done.

They also have to be competitive, driven, extroverted and highly risk-acceptant. Those are often the characteristics of our most successful economic innovators and entrepreneurs; it is not surprising that many of our most effective political figures – typically the rising stars of their parties - have the same traits. These traits, and indeed success itself, also correlates with high testosterone.

Read: Anne-Marie Slaughter's "Rebellion of an Innovation Mom".

That is the backdrop against which I conclude that Anthony Weiner should not resign, but should instead leave the decision regarding whether he can continue to serve in Congress to his constituents.

I in no way condone his behavior with women; it strikes me exactly as a pathology for which he needs treatment.

He has betrayed his wife and family; it is up to them to decide whether to forgive. And he has indeed compromised the public trust invested in him, which is why his constituents should and will have a chance to decide whether his lies mean they no longer trust him enough to have him represent them.

But consider Bill Clinton and Eliot Spitzer, to take only two of the many, many examples of powerful public men caught in sex scandals (Arnold Schwarzenegger, John Ensign, Mark Sanford, Rudy Giuliani, Gary Hart) or not caught, but revealed later (Franklin Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Nelson Rockefeller).

I for one am deeply glad that Bill Clinton did not resign; he was one of the best presidents of my lifetime and left the country in far better shape than he found it. His wife and daughter chose to forgive him and to preserve their family, which is their business, not ours. He also breached the public trust by lying, but in my view not to an extent that it affected his ability to govern successfully.

Republicans evidently make the same calculation about their candidates. It is striking that Newt Gingrich and David Vitter, to take only two recent Republican examples, were not abandoned by their supporters on the basis of sex scandals of equal severity and hypocrisy to those of comparable Democrats.

Eliot Spitzer had to resign or face legal action. The circumstances of his case were complicated by the hypocrisy of his targeting prostitution while serving as New York’s attorney general, but on the straight facts he did nothing that countless men have not done, including many in public life who have simply not been caught or have chosen to ride out the scandal.

We rightly condemn that behavior, but again, Spitzer’s wife and three daughters chose to forgive him and to maintain a close family life. (Full disclosure: I have been a friend of Spitzer’s since college and known his wife since law school.) On the other hand, Spitzer fought very hard for a wide range of public reforms in which he passionately believed. The people of New York never got a chance to decide which facet of his behavior mattered more to them.

So back to Anthony Weiner. (Full disclosure: I worked daily with Weiner’s wife, Huma Abedin, from 2009-2011, but only met Weiner once for five minutes.) His is a classic case of hubris – daring the gods and getting caught. May the resulting humiliation and comeuppance make him a better person, a better husband, and a better public servant. How he weathers this crisis and what he is willing to learn and admit from it will tell us a great deal about what he is really made of. But some of the very characteristics that led to this scandal are, properly channeled, the sources of the kind of bold, decisive, even daring action that this country needs from its leaders.

Absent criminal behavior, which is another category entirely, the issue is whether sexual misconduct undermines a politician’s ability to represent his or her constituents and contribute to the common good. It is certainly legitimate for Weiner’s Congressional colleagues to voice their views that the scandal surrounding his actions is harming the party’s agenda as a whole. But it is equally legitimate for him to insist that in the end his fate should be decided by the good citizens of his district. A government of, by, and for the people should let the people decide.

The views expressed in this article are solely those of Anne-Marie Slaughter.

Post by:
Topics: Innovation • Perspectives • Politics • Sex • United States

soundoff (626 Responses)
  1. ejhickey

    so while Weiner goes on a leave of absence for an undetermined period of time, the people he represents , have no voice in the House of Representatives.

    June 14, 2011 at 11:30 am | Reply
  2. Wherehavemoralsgone

    Men and women in power seem to be very narcississtic. I guess it takes a bold ego to hold public office. Nevertheless, our leaders should restrain their urges to display themselves sexually and should refrain from extramarital affairs. I've been told men have the need to spread their seed. Well, let them spread their seed with their wives in the privacy of their home with no cameras. I don't care how important their job is, men and women should learn to control themselves. If they can't control themselves, then they can't contraol their jobs either. I don't want people like this representing me. Their lack of morals appalls me.

    June 14, 2011 at 1:47 pm | Reply
  3. Lala

    Now Anthony you know you are less guilty that your own chief quad master, so hold on to what’s yours. This kind of stuff happens every day in our everyday lives. We have lots of children that originated from others that are being raised by nice men like you. We call those guys sperm donors.

    We just have a few questions. Was she in a hostage situation or was it an offering of love, lust or commotion. Well, the numbers are adding up and aren’t looking right.

    Hey, it doesn’t matter to me as long as it doesn’t end up having anything to do with my assets or my allotted funds that are to be replenished here very soon.

    I think the law here states that if you are married at the time of birth then you are the legal Father. It may vary state to state, so check it out.

    Looks like you get to keep your job. Next time strip down all the way and maybe you can be a model for my city to glorify the reproduction of the human species. I told the Arabs they can pick out the tits as long as I get to pick out the dicks and I asked them to send pictures right away so I could get started designing. They still haven’t sent me any pics, but I here they totally got it going on in the ocean. I thought they would be mad at me for being so open, but no, those dudes are so cool. Maybe one of those cool dudes is the parenting partner. If so, it looks like you rule as far as diplomats go.

    Anyway, as far as I say – it’s not who loses the sperm; it’s who takes up the responsibility. And, sometimes it takes not just a village to raise children, but the world.

    June 14, 2011 at 5:26 pm | Reply
  4. Roger Fager

    Please don't decide Mr Weiner is toast
    He surely has problems, but there's something to boast

    What he has gained in his peculiar position
    Is precious and thundering name recognition

    Republican hopefuls race from place to place
    "Please remember my name!"; "Please remember my face!"

    Look, if you will, what Mr Weiner has done
    Not one penny used from of his own campaign funds
    His name and his face are known near and far
    He's a spot-lighted, featured new media star

    Now, every sentence he chooses to say
    May make the front page the very next day

    Now is his time to be thinking like hell
    What a great chance to serve America well !

    His now well-known name will surely be blest
    If he skillfully steers us from our present dark mess

    Think carefully, sir, choose well every word
    You can be sure you will be heard

    A deluge of lemons on your head has been made
    Do not wimp out; just make lemonade

    (A good place to start is last week's GPS suggestion of an infrastructure bank. Particularly, if returning vets are offered good jobs on the projects. And, yes one more thing-KEEP YOUR DAMNED PANTS ON ! ! !

    June 14, 2011 at 6:11 pm | Reply
  5. mike proctor

    If the Democarats and the Republicans put this much energy into working on solution to resolve the problems facing America like putting people back to work BOY! we would not be sitting at 9.5 unemployement. Mr W einer needs to work with hisfamily and the people he work for and no one else. I'm so sick of hearing this crap over, and over for what ever reason. All new network shut the hell up about Mr Weiner you are beating a dead horse. Hey I got a news item for you "MY GRANDMA AND YOUR GRANDPA WERE SITTTING BY THE FIRE-YOUR GRANDPA GOT CAUGHT EATING MY GRANDMA SITTING BY THE FIRE". HEY! What do you think????

    June 15, 2011 at 7:48 am | Reply
  6. Cristine Majkut

    Thank you. Please send me QuickOffice for my Nokia 5800. I appreciate it.

    December 3, 2011 at 5:03 pm | Reply
  7. Jacquline Vicoy

    Hi there! Good post! But this webpage is loading incredibly slowly.

    December 8, 2011 at 4:26 am | Reply
  8. Simonne Chan

    Please guys try to find FLAKJAKT CASCADES, its a great cd.

    December 13, 2011 at 3:19 pm | Reply
  9. Bubbles - Bubble Shooter - Play Bubble Shooter Games

    Very good write-up, I'll bookmark this.

    January 26, 2012 at 12:29 am | Reply
  10. http://seguros.qweb.es/comparativa-seguros-hogar.html

    This is really fascinating, You are a very skilled blogger. I have joined your rss feed and stay up for in quest of more of your great post. Also, I've shared your site in my social networks

    September 18, 2012 at 4:04 am | Reply
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Post a comment


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,690 other followers