April 20th, 2012
06:00 AM ET

The consequences of France shifting left

Editor’s Note: The following piece, exclusive to GPS, comes from Wikistrat, the world's first massively multiplayer online consultancy.  It leverages a global network of subject-matter experts via a crowd-sourcing methodology to provide unique insights.

The countdown has begun for France’s first-round presidential election on Sunday, and while socialist challenger François Hollande is expected to beat center-right incumbent Nicolas Sarkozy, there’s a decent chance that a second run-off election will be required for Hollande to crack the 50 percent of the vote mark. Either way, we’re likely on the verge of a major political shift for one of Europe’s pillars – right after the wobbly Eurozone had hoped to close the door on its threatened dissolution.

We know what you’re thinking:  socialists, lots of new government spending, the end of the “Merkozy” tight bond between France and Germany!

So what are we to make of this looming quake?  How high will it register on the political Richter scale?  Wikistrat asked its global community of experts to ponder this, and here are the 8 points they chose to highlight.

Après Hollande, le Keynesian déluge!

Hollande’s win won’t be the last for Europe’s recently moribund Socialist movement, which is being duly revived by all this German austerity in response to the Eurozone’s ongoing fiscal/sovereign debt crisis. True, it won’t be a genuine return of Keynesian economics, which is more about government spending to jump start consumption during a business-cycle downturn, but the vote will clearly indicate the French public’s rejection of Sarkozy’s standing firm with Germany’s Angela Merkel when it comes to those debt-ravenous PIIGS (Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece and Portugal). Bottom line: we’ll see a France – and by extension Eurozone – more focused on the cause of growth over debt reduction. Also expect more hostile regulation of financial markets.

La Buffet Norme on steroids!

Exhibit #1 along these lines will be a supersized version of President Barack Obama’s recently defeated “Buffet Rule” (so named for American billionaire Warren Buffet) that promised a high minimum tax on millionaires and above. The U.S. version promised a mere 30 percent levy, whereas the French Socialists are threatening something on the order of 75 percent! Their goal? Reverse Sarkozy’s move to raise the retirement age from 60 to 62 by getting all those French fat cats to pay for it.  Having already lost its AAA rating, with public debt at 90 percent of GDP and public spending at more than half of GDP, the Socialists are doubling down on government in the country that invented big government.

Le nouveau visage of Euroskepticism

Traditionally, it’s been the European Right that has fought European integration, but the continent’s current “Iron Lady” (Germany’s Merkel) has recently stood tall as its pragmatic champion. Conversely, Europe’s socialists have typically supported the European ideal, but with austerity as the current pricetag, expect that to change with Hollande’s ascent.  So say good-bye to Sarkozy’s hyperactivity (for example, his dream of a European Union-cum-Mediterranean Union), as Hollande’s just-say-non attitude marks France as the new poster child of Euroskepticism.

EZ come, EZ go

Hollande’s spend-heavy platform will exacerbate France’s economic problems, sending the country into a downward spiral and dealing a final blow to the Eurozone. By becoming the über-pig-among-PIIGS, Germany’s austerity pitch will go by the wayside and Eurozone defections will follow. The EZ’s resulting implosion will trigger the much-feared “double dip” across the global economy, and many global leaders will ultimately blame Paris for this “betrayal,” reducing France’s international standing to a new low point.  Sacre duh!

The return of Gaullism = NATO’s death spiral

Sarkozy brought France back into NATO’s command fold, but Hollande has promised the swiftest possible withdrawal of French forces from Afghanistan. He has also resumed the normal, pre-Sarkozy rhetoric on strengthening the EU’s Common Security and Defense Policy – France’s alternative to NATO.  Amidst Washington’s purposeful strategic “pivot” to East Asia, this will accelerate the decline of the already drifting European military alliance. History will record the Libyan intervention as NATO’s last-gasp operation.

Does Turkey get a leg up?

The Socialists have always been much more receptive to Turkey’s much-delayed accession into the EU, but in the every-nation-for-itself dynamic that Hollande’s free-spending ways may well trigger, it’s not all that clear there will be anything left for Ankara to join. What is clear is that a rudderless NATO would leave Turkey firmly in the driver’s seat in both war-torn Syria and the wider Arab Spring. That’s a new thing, but not necessarily a bad thing.

Meet the new boss. Same as the old boss.

Let’s remember that there’s the candidate for office and then there’s the man after he settles into that big old chair of power. Hollande can promise all the change he wants – just like candidate Obama did – only to find his options far more constrained once sworn into office. This is – at best – a center-right-to-center-left shift, and that might just be the best of both worlds: the marriage of a socialist agenda to forcefully conservative government machinery. It could be just what the EZ doctor ordered: just enough capitulation to France’s burgeoning populist anger to avoid a far more serious political meltdown.  The French said it first a long time ago: plus ça change (the more things change), plus c'est la même chose (the more they stay the same).

Le comeback enfant?

Don’t count Sarkozy out. The first round of voting is an exercise in populist spleen-venting, while the second round is a far more serious affair – electing the President of the Republic.  Compare Sunday’s vote to the just-concluded Republican primary race and you’ll get the picture. Sarkozy may look a whole lot more acceptable once it devolves into mano a mano slugfest. It’s a short interval between the two votes – just a mere two weeks!  And both candidates will struggle to win over the small-but-crucial blocks that went to extremist candidates.  Hollande is the Romney in this race, and boring “change agents” face an uphill tactical battle against charismatic incumbents. The undecided vote is still large as of today. Who knows how big it will be on 6 May?


That’s Wikistrat's “wisdom of the crowd” for this week.  Now tell us how you see the election and its aftermath playing out.

Topics: Europe • Politics

soundoff (150 Responses)
  1. Jason Glugla

    Those darned socialists, what they need is a government of by and for the corporations.

    April 22, 2012 at 10:09 am | Reply
  2. abdulameer

    One reason for the shift to the left in France is the fact that nearly all of the Moslems in France who are eligible to vote are voting for the socialists. There is a similar phenomenon all over Europe, and in America, too. The Moslems know that the leftists will pander by permitting increased Moslem immigration and increased special privileges domestically. There is a lot more here than just Keynsian economics.

    April 22, 2012 at 10:36 am | Reply
  3. AlexShch

    Looks like Sarkozy is on his way out. The next stage will be the second round –> final defeat –> corruption investigation –> criminal prosecution –> conviction –> long-term prison sentence –> and, possibly, divorce at the end of the road.

    April 22, 2012 at 7:15 pm | Reply
  4. Josh

    The Warren Buffet? Is that a new all you can eat restaurant? Come on fact checkers and editors, it makes you look 2-bit when you spell famous people's names incorrectly.

    April 23, 2012 at 12:15 am | Reply
  5. Jack

    "Le Buffet Norme" and "le comeback enfant"? Clearly French is not really your forte, so you could've at least have someone to proofread those.

    Anyways, "la France forte"? Oh yes, Sarko. It's strong enough to fire you. Effective May 6th, so pack your bags.

    April 23, 2012 at 12:36 am | Reply
  6. RIck Springfield

    France shift left? It has shifted so far left that it has gone around the world and back. This is a very bad time to visit France as they have the most strictest laws against public expression of religion. We were warned on a company trip last year not to do a diner prayer at any restaurant. They told us about police arresting an American couple who had prayed at a fancy French bistro. France outlaws any public expression of religion. You also should not drive in France. They have been known to hold Americans in jail until they pay up to a $00,000 bond for a fender bender. France is not your grandfather's France, its a modern hotbed of Islamic hate and ire.

    April 23, 2012 at 5:03 am | Reply
    • lordpet

      stop it Rick. I go to France all the time and what you are talking about is pure BS. "France outlaws any public display of religion?" What, they shut down Notre Dame? Get off the crack. They have more freedom there than we do here, all across the board. Plus average people don't have to worry about the costs of health care or education. Find some other straw man.

      April 23, 2012 at 8:44 am | Reply
  7. fmaack

    The Socialist Party of France isn't even that left. First off, the original Presidential candidate was Dominique Strauss-Kahn, the managing director of the IMF, a neo-conservative organization which profits off the backs of the poor in the 3rd world. Secondly, look at their policies: "In May 2011, the French centre-left think tank Terra Nova edited a "Left strategy for 2012" report, which suggests that workers should not continue to be a main subject of the Socialist Party's campaign platform, considering that the working class has lost its political significance and has moved toward the National Front nowadays". Sounds pretty centrist in terms of political parties in the Western world.

    "It advises the party to revitalize its platform and its voter base by emphasizing its progressive views on youth and women and by targeting ethnic minorities, precarious workers and academia."

    Targetting ethnic minorities. Sounds like this is the GOP not the Socialist Party.

    Even the EU Parliament has a party called the Progressive Allance of Socialists and Democrats. Socialism and the EU should be incompatible.

    April 25, 2012 at 3:30 pm | Reply
1 2

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.