August 3rd, 2012
04:42 PM ET

Diplomacy over Syria may be about to get messier – and perhaps more fruitful

By Chris Brown, Special to CNN

Editor’s note: Chris Brown is professor of international relations at the London School of Economics.  The views expressed are the writer’s own.

The resignation of Kofi Annan from his role as U.N. envoy to Syria does no more than recognize what has been clear for most of the past three months, namely that in this case, the standard peacemaking model of a ceasefire followed by talks between the parties to produce a compromise has no chance of success.

A year ago, such an initiative might have worked. But too much blood has now been spilled, and, crucially, the conflict has become overtly sectarian in a way that wasn’t the case in its early stages.

Annan, in his valedictory message in the Financial Times yesterday, is still inclined to blame disunity in the Security Council for the failure of his plan. “Only a united international community can compel both sides to engage in a peaceful political transition,” he argues. This should, I think, be revised to “not even a united international community can compel both sides to engage in a peaceful political transition if neither side conceives it to be in their interest to do so.”

Syrian President Bashar al-Assad knows very well that “peaceful political transition” means, at best, exile for him and his family. His supporters fear that such a transition could only empower the Sunni majority in Syria at the expense of Druze, Christian and Alawite minorities, while the opposition clearly believes it can win outright without sharing power with regime elements.  This is a recipe for a fight to the finish.

The key question is just how bloody this fight will be, and this is something that the external supporters of the parties can actually still influence – there’s still a role here for the international community, although not one that can be exercised via the U.N. Security Council. Interestingly, the shift of emphasis to action in the U.N. General Assembly may actually be a good thing, given that one of the goals of international action should be to push Russia and China towards ending support for al-Assad. Russia in particular has a lot of political capital tied up in Syria, and it isn’t going to change tack unless the costs of supporting the current regime are increased substantially.

Western disapproval can’t achieve this outcome because Russia automatically discounts Western criticism.  Criticism from the “global south” is another matter.  For the last two decades, Russia and China have generally opposed “humanitarian interventions” and the operation of the “responsibility to protect” doctrine as expressions of modern imperialism, and have usually received support in the global south for so doing.  Syria has been different; they didn’t enjoy being on the wrong end of a 13-2 vote in the Security Council earlier this year, and the overwhelming passing of the Saudi resolution in the Assembly today will have increased Russian and Chinese discomfort.

Talk of the influence of “global public opinion” may seem rather old-fashioned, but it’s certainly the case that Russian diplomats will have been watching how global opinion leaders such as Brazil (yes), India (abstained) and South Africa yes) voted today. Russian President Vladimir Putin may enjoy defying Western public opinion, but he won’t relish being locked in the same room diplomatically with Venezuela, Iran, Cuba and the other members of the international awkward squad.

External supporters of the opposition to the Syrian regime have a different task, which is to help this opposition develop a coherent identity, and in particular to produce a plausible “government-in-exile” based on the Free Syrian Army, preferably including some substantial non-Sunni representation, and excluding jihadists.

It may well be that the fighting in Syria degenerates into a stalemate, with de factor opposition control of much of the countryside, while the regime controls Damascus and Aleppo. Alternatively, the regime may suddenly collapse from within as more and more army units decide to switch sides. Either way, the existence of an alternative government would be a game changer, potentially stabilizing part of the country or, in the latter case, all of Syria.

The role of Turkey is going to be crucial here: no other country has equivalent standing within the region or the muscle to make an alternative government effective. And, of course, the geography of the region means that Turkey is going to be in the middle of the action whether it wants to be or not.  The United States, Britain and France would be well advised to let Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan make the running in this matter, offering support and guarantees of security, but not trying to control the game.

All this ultimately means that although one phase of diplomacy may have ended, there is still a role – or even many roles – for the international community. Indeed, it may well be that the scrapping of the Annan peace plan actually clears the path for a less coherent, messier, but ultimately more fruitful kind of diplomacy.  The people of Syria will certainly hope for better than what they’ve seen so far.

Post by:
Topics: Brazil • Middle East • Russia • Syria • United Nations

soundoff (22 Responses)
  1. melvin polatnick

    Orders from Allah come in a whisper; each listener gets a separate message. That is why there is so much violence among followers of Sharia Law. Any attempt to organize Islamists under a central government is a waste, they must be allowed to live separate but holy ways.

    August 3, 2012 at 7:53 pm | Reply
    • Noreen

      Please keep Allah out of this, and your prejudices. Sharia law has absolutely nothing to do with this conflict (it's not even implemented in most Arab countries). This is a conflict about freedom, rights, dignity, and having a better future for the next generation....or is that simply impossible to imagine for Arabs??!!!
      And just FYI Allah means God in Arabic, both Christian Arabs and Jewish Arabs used Allah in their prayers to mean God, and Muslims believe in that same God, so stop the ignorance.

      August 3, 2012 at 11:00 pm | Reply
      • muslim traitor

        God is God. Allah is a pig in wolf's clothing. Allah incites his cult to kill innocents. Allah is the creation of a pedopbile,
        a liar and a .murderer.

        August 4, 2012 at 7:33 am |
      • Moyoni mwa Mwafrika

        You are just emphasising Melvin's point, that different people interpret Sharia law differently,there are extremists in every religion, and liberals and conservatives.However, that is not the problem Syria is facing, the differences in religion is an expired excuse. The real problem with Syria is the interference of the international community, if it was about human rights then the rest of the world should invade the United States first, then we can take up arms against Syria. A government in exile will be no solution either, if Assad hasn't quit after all the violence and Annan's 'diplomacy', why would he quit as a result of a bunch of foreign puppets trying to run his affairs?A government in exile will be recognized by the faction in the General Assembly who are anti- Assad while the ones who are pro-Assad will still recognize Assad's government, and we will be back to square one, Syria will still be in tatters.

        August 4, 2012 at 2:01 pm |
  2. J. Foster Dulles

    Everbody knows that the situation in Syria will get messier but by being more fruitful, did this Chris Brown imply that Syria may become another pseudo-democratic state created by the U.S. and it's worthless NATO allies? I definately hope not!

    August 4, 2012 at 1:40 am | Reply
    • muslim traitor

      What would you like to see mohammed? A nation under Allah that stones innocent girls and enslaves humanity.

      August 4, 2012 at 7:38 am | Reply
  3. j. von hettlingen

    Turkey has no doubt a very important role to play. If Erdogan succeeds in helping all the ethnic and religious elements to unite under one umbrella in the post-Assad Syria, it would also relieve him of the worries about the Kurdish aspiration in Syria, which might also inspire the Kurds in Turkey to break away and join their Syrian brethren.

    August 4, 2012 at 3:47 am | Reply
    • j. von hettlingen

      Indeed Annan might have had more luck a year ago in his negotiating task. Now the conflict has reached a point of no return and has become a zero-sum game. In March 2011 the international community was quick to act in the Libyan crisis, which saw the demise of Gaddafi's regime six months later.
      Nontheless the UN can still play a crucial role in maintaing peace in a post-Assad Syria, as a new overture will be played following Assad's swansong.

      August 4, 2012 at 3:57 am | Reply
      • muslim traitor

        Hey Abdul do you remember how hard the un tried to stop the insanity only to be stopped by Russia and. China. Muslims have memory problems. Once Muslims taste blood no one can stop them its like trying to stop pigs from eating. Besides Muslims love martyrs.

        August 4, 2012 at 7:44 am |
    • GokTurk

      I hope the Kurds do try something.... 😉

      August 4, 2012 at 2:25 pm | Reply
  4. deniz boro

    🙂 I've got the nicest seat in the arena to watch the program here.

    August 6, 2012 at 7:33 pm | Reply
  5. Joseph McCarthy/Quigley/LyndsieGraham/krm1007 ©™/Joe Collins/J. Foster Dulles/Marine5484

    I am a useless piece of camel dung. I post anti American, anti GB, anti semite, anti India, anti modern anything because I am a good moooooslem. I steal people's monikers because I am so ashamed of myself and post the most stupid comment. When people get angry with me, I claim insanity. I am the same guy.

    August 18, 2012 at 9:04 am | Reply

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.