U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve needs fixing – fast
September 21st, 2012
11:09 AM ET

U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve needs fixing – fast

By Blake Clayton, Special to CNN

Editor’s note: Blake Clayton is a fellow for energy and national security at the Council on Foreign Relations. He recently wrote a major new study on the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve published by the Council, available here.

The chaos in Libya, Egypt and elsewhere has the oil market on edge, and with good reason. But there is another scare among oil traders, much closer to home, one that could be catastrophic for gasoline prices if oil imports are disrupted this fall.

Speculation among experts is rife that the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) is no longer able to release oil to the market as quickly as the Department of Energy claims it can. If true – and there is good reason to believe it is – it could destroy the White House’s ability to prevent oil prices from skyrocketing if the commotion in the Middle East worsens. This needs to be fixed – and fast.

The SPR is the nation’s last defense against a dire loss of oil supplies capable of sending the economy into a tailspin. The potential for a military confrontation between Israel and Iran, which could require the United States to release oil from the SPR, makes this resource more critical than ever.

But analysts are skeptical that the U.S. federal government is as functional as advertised. The Department of Energy has offered only a weak denial of these allegations. For a lesson in how a lack of transparency can end up hurting the very market it aims to calm, Washington need look no further than Saudi Arabia.

Saudi Arabia holds the lion’s share of OPEC spare capacity – in other words, oil left unused but which could be brought online quickly and sustainably if need be. Its exalted place among producers stems in part from its ability to convince the market that it can plug an unforeseen gap in supplies, and thus keep prices stable.

But traders have balked for years at Riyadh’s claims that it can quickly ramp up its production as high as it says it can. Analysts are rightfully skeptical: after all, its assertions are based on untested assumptions, and the Kingdom has an incentive to overestimate them. Moreover, the Saudis are loath to give outsiders information about their domestic oil industry, a veil of secrecy that provides fodder for market speculation.

Americans love to pick at Saudi opacity, yet Washington itself faces similar problems.  The SPR is a powerful tool for reassuring the market that the United States, along with other major consuming countries, stands ready to stabilize the market in the case of a severe supply disruption. But market participants are becoming increasingly cynical about whether the SPR is up to the challenge.

Edward Morse, a former U.S. energy official who now leads Citigroup’s commodities research team, argued compellingly earlier this year that recent years’ changes to North American oil infrastructure have rendered the SPR “significantly less usable than advertised.” Many of the pipelines that could deliver the oil to market quickly can no longer move SPR oil. Instead, the oil would need to be exported by sea, a method that may take seven times longer than it would via pipelines. This difference in flow rates would have big consequences: the SPR would not come close to covering the loss of Iranian crude exports, for example, should they be interrupted.

An anonymous official at the Department of Energy roundly rejected this sort of speculation in March: the Department is “confident,” he said, “that, if needed, it could effectively react to a situation” requiring it to inject into the market the 4.25 million barrels per day of oil it claims it can. He stressed that the department “conducts routine and thorough analysis of commercial distribution capabilities to ensure accurate assessments.”

This rebuttal falls well short of what is needed to reassure the market that the SPR can do what U.S. officials have long said it can. If Washington is sincere about dispelling growing doubts, it needs to give traders more evidence than an unproven, anonymous “not so.”

U.S. officials should investigate the issue via a test drawdown and sale, and publicly disclose their findings. If market participants harbor doubts about the flow capacity of the U.S. SPR, they may discount its ability to help offset any sudden supply shortages, rendering it a less effective tool for calming the market.

As any Saudi oil official knows, the market will remain skeptical of words until they are backed by actions. Greater transparency about the SPR’s capabilities, particularly in light of profound recent changes in the North American oil landscape, is critical.

Post by:
Topics: Middle East • Oil • Saudi Arabia • United States

soundoff (7 Responses)
  1. j. von hettlingen

    "The chaos in Libya, Egypt and elsewhere has the oil market on edge", I doubt what the author said. Geopolitics might play a role, but the situation has been a tense one for the last six months.
    Yes, oil prices might have gone up, as winter is approaching. The world economy is slowing down and so is manufacturing, which would lead to lower oil consumption.

    September 23, 2012 at 4:01 am | Reply
  2. michael kors outlet store

    You'll get a method. These people alter your own actions favorably. These people improve oneself confidence. Using the buying of the Michael kors purses, you'd be immediately in a position to enhance your own self-image favorably. Increase which, they'd increase upward your own charm as well as personal inspiration proactively. An additional the majority of interesting advantage of purchasing Michael kors purses is actually they might provide you with a satisfaction as well as reduce your own tension permanently. Following they're really expert purses by which you receive the fashionand glamour strikingly. Consequently for those who have already been captivated because of Michael kors purses, make sure you don't wait to make contact with together with your purses organization on the internet. It might certainly supply you the very best Michael kors purses providers. michael kors outlet store http://michaelkorsoutletstore2013.webstarts.com/

    March 13, 2013 at 1:25 am | Reply
  3. lista stron

    Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So nice to search out any person with some original ideas on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this web site is one thing that is wanted on the web, someone with just a little originality. helpful job for bringing something new to the internet! lista stron http://supcato.waw.pl/add/

    May 2, 2013 at 10:02 am | Reply
  4. ThomasPlum



    Air Max Zero Fragment
    Converse Womens High Tops
    Air Max 2016 Blue And Orange
    Nike Air Max 2016 Boys
    2016 Air Max Red

    March 31, 2017 at 10:21 pm | Reply
  5. RichardBow

    Adidas Sl 72 Blau
    Ensuring that your puppy is well trained will resulted in a more happy and a lot more satisfying romantic relationship in between you and your family pet. Dog training can also be a wonderful way to develop a connection along with your family pet.

    In no way make using a wine that you just do not take pleasure in the flavoring of. When vino chefs downward during the cooking food procedure, it concentrates. Any tastes that you do nothing like could be more common, and that means you is not going to just like the preference of the food you possess worked well so difficult to get ready.
    Nike Roshe Run 2017

    April 19, 2017 at 9:47 pm | Reply

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.