By Fareed Zakaria
The events in Egypt over the last week have been fascinating but also bewildering. Most of us don’t quite know what to make of them. Is what has happened a good thing or a bad thing? Let’s start with some basic facts.
The government that was deposed in Egypt was an elected government. Mohamed Morsy’s Freedom and Justice Party, won the presidential election, the parliamentary elections, and a referendum to approve a new Egyptian constitution. So there’s no getting around it – this was the party that represented the wishes of the Egyptian people as expressed through the ballot box.
On the other hand, the government ruled in an arbitrary and highhanded manner and in many, many cases, violated human rights and outlawed its political opponents. President Morsy announced that his decrees were above judicial scrutiny. He banned all members of the previous ruling party from participating in politics for life. He did little about attacks on Egyptian’s Christian minority. The Muslim Brotherhood, of which Morsy was a lifelong member, had promised not to seek the presidency or a parliamentary majority and it reneged on both pledges, creating this new Freedom and Justice Party as a façade.
More from GPS: Bipartisan cluelessness on Egypt
In 1996, I wrote an essay in Foreign Affairs describing the rise of what I called “illiberal democracies” – elected governments that were abusing individual rights and freedoms. The Morsy government is a textbook example of such a regime. But it is important to note that the current system in Egypt does not look like one that is upholding liberty in any sense either. Indeed the more the arrests and crackdowns continue, the more it looks like the old Mubarak-military complex, crowned once more over the ashes of democracy.
This has been Egypt and the Arab world’s tragedy. These lands are caught between repressive dictatorships and illiberal democracies, and from this vicious cycle there does not seem much space for liberty to break out.
More from GPS: Six lessons for Egypt
What should the United States do to help the cause of freedom and stability in Egypt? Well, a suspension of U.S. aid would plunge an already bankrupt country into deeper chaos. But Washington should announce that it will continue its aid for a limited period, say two months, while it determines whether the new government is in fact moving to restore genuine democracy in Egypt.
More specifically it should ask for three things:
- An end to arbitrary arrests of the Muslim Brotherhood or any groups or people for political opposition. Also, the end of the crackdown on media in all forms.
- The writing of a new constitution through a process that includes all major voices in Egyptian life
- The scheduling of parliamentary and presidential elections in which everyone can participate, including and especially the Muslim brotherhood.
If these conditions are not met, than we have no alternative than to recognize the reality that this is not the restoration of democracy, nor a path to moderation and inclusion. This is a pretty-old fashioned military coup. And it should be dealt with as such.
Fareed, you know nothing!!!! Moursi was elected by 12% of Egyptians. Your president Obama is supporting MB , can you answer this question, why is he doing that? and please don't deny it or I will say again " you know nothing" my adivice to you it is better to shut up than speak nonesense.
Mr. Zakaria does manage to skim bits & pieces from all over (Plagiarize), apply his half baked, under-researched analysis and present it as gospel.
What amazes me is how so many people still believe he is all fair & balanced and take that literally as the final word. I do try to read many of his articles, ONLY to see what kind of spin he introduces and I have never been disappointed.
Dear Mr. Zakaria:
With all due respect for your political Analysis, I would like you to remember that the Egyptian Military Move was solely to execute the well of 33 million Egyptians who rose against a terrorist group called the muslim brotherhood who were trying and still trying to abduct the country and drag Egypt into the dark days of history of Islamic khelafa. I wish that The United States of America realizes that the way to freedom and liberty in Egypt is only by standing against this islamic project. Remember september 11 was the act of those Jehady muslims who now want to rule a 7000 years old nation. I hope that the Americans React according to what they preach about Democracy. What is happening in Egypt is a Rise of the people againest an islamic dectator and an islamic terrorist ruling.
Is what has happened a good thing or a bad thing?
If you look at the History of Syria, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Libya, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Pakistan, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Turkey, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Lebanon you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Somalia, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Iran, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Saudi Arabia, you will have your answer.
If you look at the History of Afghanistan, you will have your answer.
It is Islam.
It is Islam the root of all problems in the middle east, brain washed people!!!
I SLAM is the problem!!
Zakaria is Muslim him self I can tell from his name & talking as if he belongs to the MB group. As an Egyptian American I am asking you to only watch the videos of MB throwing the children from top of the roof & after they are on the ground they continue slamming them with sticks till they die. One of those children moms passed away yesterday. Then after you watch the video state your opinion about MB ruling Egypt.
Please Stop with your clueless comments, you have no idea what is the Egyptian people went through during this past year so keep you comment & suggestion to your self you are creating enemies to CNN & to you
You will not have peace in Egypt or other Middle-East countries unless you separate between religion and state! There should never be any political party with religious background never!!!
Same Iraq and Africa , all the region are tribal , They will never understand each other.
Hasn't CNN figured out that this guy has no clue about Islamic matters? He's an Indian Muslim, he doesn't know how the fanatics in the wider Islamic world think. He was foolish enough to believe the Arab Spring was a bunch of liberal students demanding human rights. Now he's an expert again?
Wait a minute....
Wasn't it Zakaria who said a few days ago "US should stay out of it"? Welcome to Schizo-ville, population 1.
I think they should kill each other for a while and then blame the US and Jews.
What Egypt needs more than anything is a Military that will pledge to incorporate and defend a new law for all Egyptians above all other laws. That law currently exists, it protects all citizens of a country, minorities and majorities.
It is a law all must obey for it requires respect of the rights of all citizens. It is a universal law that all parties would want applied to themselves but that in turn means it is applied to all other groups equally. Send over a copy of the First Amendment. It is First and foremost for a reason.
This is what Fareed seems to say:
"IF these conditions are not met, THEN we have no alternative than to recognize the reality that this is
NOT the restoration of democracy, nor a path to moderation and inclusion;
THIS IS a pretty-old fashioned military coup, and it should be dealt with as such."
That's how it is though translitterated:
'If these conditions are not met, than we have no alternative than to recognize the reality that this is not the restoration of democracy, nor a path to moderation and inclusion. This is a pretty-old fashioned military coup. And it should be dealt with as such.'
Don't you think there's a BIG difference on making the last two phrases separate from the first opening IF – concession?
Well, I don't know what's going on in publisher's mind, but I do think, and I think he should also note the difference.
None of that will work, Zakaria, and you know it won't work.
Wherever Islam goes, it tolerates no other religion. Your plan cannot succeed, because it IGNORES that basically, Islam is a dictatorial and controlling religion, that tolerates NO OTHER!
As such, in a traditionally secular country, it is unworkable.
I need to comment above about point #3: "The scheduling of parliamentary and presidential elections in which everyone can participate, including and especially the Muslim brotherhood." THIS WILL NEVER HAPPEN – EGYPT IS DONE WITH THE MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD – THEY ARE OUTLAWED.
Which means #1:"An end to arbitrary arrests of the Muslim Brotherhood or any groups or people for political opposition. Also, the end of the crackdown on media in all forms." CANNOT HAPPEN EITHER – AS LONG AS MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD CONTINUES TO BE FUNDED BY HAMAS GROUP AND CONTINUE TO HARASS THE PEOPLE AND THE ARMY – THE NEW GOVERNMENT THAT IS YET TO BE FORMED – MUST ABOLISH THE MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD ONCE AND FOR ALL FROM EGYPT COMPLETELY!!!
All the failures that have happened with attempts to implement a democracy in various country's in the region have occured because there hasn't been an effort to implement one critical democratic priciple. The separation of church and state. I doubt that any Mulim faction would want to try it. It seems to be in the Muslim nature to intergate religion into government. Doing so will result in failure every time. Religion and politics just don't mix. They have to stay separate.
Fareed seems to assume that democracy as an ideal is beyond reproach. The Am founders also knew that democracy can be a tyranny as well. If people are ignorant or subject to prejudice, the govt they elect may be no better. The truth about democracy which is also its downfall, is that officials are not elected to represent good ideas or even the commonweal. They are elected to represent interests, and it doesn't take very long for the rich and powerful interests to assert themselves to be the interests that officials will represent. Besides, elected representatives are merely representing the people, not what the people want or need. Am represents corporatist interests, not the common good.
Is Fareed gay? Let's figure this out in this forum. Don't be gay and state your opinion.
maybe the USA will get lucky and these stone aged people will start killing each other!!!!!!!!!!!!
For Mr. Zakaria and all the others crying over the fall of the Muslim Brotherhood. Let me remind you that Hitler was a freely elected leader too. I am sure you would have been complaining over his ouster as well.
Nice job. So you're antidemocratic. Hitler was NOT democratically elected. Don't listen to internet myths and lies. He was elected in a corrupt system in a backroom deal.
It must be the other than it's mother the only ancient in aspects that had the scale ................First or Second?
with out my families blood that would not be possible for in these time we are involved. If the scale of fairytales back in the early writting would have displayed then the theory of the words "come from" would be specific too the actual familes for example.
The twilight zone food shortages and the name of such machine during that time for thought when hydrations was________ via ie, military??? or there in the scale of stranger of types of aliens in the old testament!
It's funny how this article is completely undemocratic and 'AID' is only in name. It's really 'BRIBE to the military for control . No one knows really where that money goes. Only the CIA knows.
$1.3 billion of American aid to Egypt goes to the military, not to the Egyptian people. So how would cutting that aid hurt them? It seems the USA is more comfortable to have a friendly tinpot dictator in charge rather than a democratically elected president.
The Global Public Square is where you can make sense of the world every day with insights and explanations from CNN's Fareed Zakaria, leading journalists at CNN, and other international thinkers. Join GPS editor Jason Miks and get informed about global issues, exposed to unique stories, and engaged with diverse and original perspectives.
Every week we bring you in-depth interviews with world leaders, newsmakers and analysts who break down the world's toughest problems.
CNN U.S.: Sundays 10 a.m. & 1 p.m ET | CNN International: Find local times
Buy the GPS mug | Books| Transcripts | Audio
Connect on Facebook | Twitter | GPS@cnn.com
Buy past episodes on iTunes! | Download the audio podcast
Check out all of Fareed's Washington Post columns here:
Obama as a foreign policy president?
Why Snowden should stand trial in U.S.
Hillary Clinton's truly hard choice
China's trapped transition
Obama should rethink Syria strategy
Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
RSS - Posts
Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.
Join 4,858 other followers