By John Cookson
Fareed’s ‘Book of the Week’ is Zachary Karabell’s The Leading Indicators: A Short History of the Numbers That Rule Our World. GPS's John Cookson spoke with him about trade with China and the troubles of telling just how well an economy is doing.
Last year the United States imported $314 billion more in goods and services from China than it exported to the country. This trade deficit is cited by some as an example of America’s economic decline and China’s ascendency. You say in the book, "not so fast."
I do say, "not so fast" because I think we are calculating the way goods and products are made in a way that goods and products are no longer made. The assumption that every product comes from one country is simply not true. It's something that many people who know this world better than I do have recognized and have tried to show the ways in which an iPhone and iPad are made up of multiple components from many different countries. If you were able to break down where the value of each of these products goes you would find that it goes to lots of different places, and it especially goes to whoever has created the intellectual property in the first place. But most of that is invisible for trade numbers. Because there isn't a system of breaking down every manufacturing good in the world into its component parts, we end up ascribing all the value to a country that has the factory, that did the final assembly, missing out on all these other aspects of how goods are made.
You mentioned the iPhone, which of course advertises itself as being "Designed by Apple in California" and "Assembled in China."
The reality is that from a trade perspective and official trade figures there is no "designed in."
You write that there are problems not only with measuring trade, but also with measuring the overall size of the economy. Should gross domestic product (GDP) and other economic measurements be replaced with something different, such as a poll of how happy we are?
I don't think replacing our numbers with other numbers is really the answer. A happiness index is appealing to people because it purports to measure the value of things, the value of life and the quality of life. But all it does is look at a different set of variables than GDP. There's no one number that can capture our experience of are we collectively and individually doing well. The kind of will-o'-the-wisp of we are going to find a number, a really simple number, and if it goes up that means we are all doing well and if it goes down we are doing badly – that's just silly on the face of it.
Considering all the shortcomings of the measurements that are intended to tell us how an economy is doing, how is the U.S. economy really doing?
There's no one answer to that question. And granted, the world is full of "one answers" to that question. What I try to do in the book is help us understand that, first of all, the economy is just a creation of numbers. It isn't a physical, tangible entity that we can easily measure.
If by "the economy" one means GDP, which is usually the default number that people go to to answer the question of how the economy is doing, GDP only measures how much stuff we are making and how much stuff we are consuming at market prices, that we can measure. And those last two parts are probably the most crucial – at market prices, that we can measure.
There's a lot that GDP doesn't include. The limitations of GDP have long been understood, but the degree to which we continue to cleave to it remains pretty much unmitigated.I don’t think there's an answer to how the U.S. economy is doing unless one starts becoming more specific. What is the earning potential of most people relative to their cost of living? How do we even decide what cost of living is? Companies are doing really well. People who are wage earners are not doing so well. Both of those things are true, while simultaneously the GDP could be growing. So, I don’t think there are the answers we would like, which I know is not nearly as satisfying as if I could come up with the perfect other number that would then answer that question. But I think that's a dream world rather than the real world.
Exactly what does this clown John Cookson take us for? This country is in an economic decline because the right-wing fanatics in Washington won't change the direction that this country is going. As long as we keep keep on spending more than half our budget on the military, this will be the case!
Reason is our only hope and politics disregards this because it would mean we use common sense. Common sense means we use a method different how we run our political system. I heard once a Senator spends twice the time on raising money than "official business". It seems all to obvious to me we are failing. An F for a grade for the parties to compete for power. There is too much graft for a solution to arise in Washington which either robs the middle class or use the military industrial complex to create our next problem.
Import from Europe, please. We have great quality products ´Made in EU´. Thank you.
EU made kwok zucking kwok zuckers?
Give the $314 billion for imports from NATO countries – – and China gets ´zero – 0´!
Spot on @ Alan Kinsman! They are nothing more than high end welfare recipients. With the work ethics of vipers! Our government is too phat with lazy selfish clowns! Time to tighten it up some!
USA should not import that much from Asia (no china, no s.korea, ...), as they are not in NATO. NATO member countries should get the business.
Endearingly insightful, but what do this indicators infer to future endevours, should there be disparity of what to accept and what to consider however small.
The Global Public Square is where you can make sense of the world every day with insights and explanations from CNN's Fareed Zakaria, leading journalists at CNN, and other international thinkers. Join GPS editor Jason Miks and get informed about global issues, exposed to unique stories, and engaged with diverse and original perspectives.
Every week we bring you in-depth interviews with world leaders, newsmakers and analysts who break down the world's toughest problems.
CNN U.S.: Sundays 10 a.m. & 1 p.m ET | CNN International: Find local times
Buy the GPS mug | Books| Transcripts | Audio
Connect on Facebook | Twitter | GPS@cnn.com
Buy past episodes on iTunes! | Download the audio podcast
Check out all of Fareed's Washington Post columns here:
Obama as a foreign policy president?
Why Snowden should stand trial in U.S.
Hillary Clinton's truly hard choice
China's trapped transition
Obama should rethink Syria strategy
Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
RSS - Posts
Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.
Join 4,863 other followers