June 24th, 2014
02:31 PM ET

Iraq’s minorities left between scorpions and a hard place

By Letta Tayler, Special to CNN

Editor’s note: Letta Tayler is a senior researcher at Human Rights Watch. You can follow her Follow @LettaTayler. The views expressed are her own.

Sunday wasn’t a good day in northern Iraq’s al-Hamdaniyah district. The previous night, Sunni extremist militants had snatched 26 Shia Turkmen from their homes.  For the second week, residents had no running water and almost no electricity. The local hospital was almost out of medicine, and the doctor running the emergency room was fretting about scorpions.

“We still have anti-venom for the snake bites, but nothing left for the scorpions,” said the doctor, Zakar Bayati.  “The scorpions here can kill small children.”

Bayati, a pediatrician, had stepped in as emergency room chief because most of the hospital’s doctors were huddled in their homes 25 kilometers northwest in Mosul, Iraq’s second-largest city, too scared to travel to work. The hospital usually had 15 doctors, Bayati said. During my visit to the hospital on Tuesday in Bakhdid, the district’s largest town, they had four.

Mosul fell June 10 to the armed militant group Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS). Thousands of Iraqi government troops and civilians fled east across al-Hamdaniyah and other parts of the Nineveh Plains, a religiously diverse region that includes Assyrian and Chaldean Christians, Turkmen, Shabaks, and predominantly Kurdish Yazidis. ISIS followed, coming within 100 meters of Bakhdida, a local police official and two generals from the area said in interviews there.

The drive to Badkdida, a 30-kilometer trip west from Kurdistan’s capital, Erbil, involved passing five peshmerga checkpoints. The eastbound lane was jammed with cars of Iraqis fleeing to already overflowing Kurdish refugee camps.

Authorities in Kurdistan, an autonomous region of northeastern Iraq that has designs on the oil-rich Nineveh Plains, have dispatched 1,500 Kurdish peshmerga troops to al-Hamdaniyah to keep ISIS at bay. But the security officials, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said that hundreds of ISIS fighters remained in in Namrud, a township just 5 kilometers from Bakhdida past the peshmerga cordon.

The night before my visit, ISIS gunmen had entered al-Shansiat, another community just south of the peshmerga line in al-Hamdaniyah. They seized 26 Shia Turkmen, prompting scores of other Shia families from those two minority groups to flee the area, the security officials and a local Christian leader said. “We don’t know what they will do to them – take them to fight or kill them,” the local police official said.

Around that same time, ISIS was rounding up and executing groups of Shia Turkmen in villages outside of the city of Kurkuk, to the south.

ISIS has refrained from fighting the peshmerga, but al-Hamdaniya residents feared that standoff might not last. “DA’ASH is too close,” said Badr, an Assyrian shopkeeper in Bakhdida, using the Arabic acronym for ISIS. “And what happens if the peshmerga leave?”

Next to Badr’s shop, the local kebab restaurant and most other stores were shut or empty. As part of a nationwide shortage of basic services caused by the fighting between ISIS and the Iraqi government, most al-Hamdaniyah residents have no running water and almost no electricity or fuel, grinding most activities to a halt.

Religious minorities in al-Hamdaniyah and the rest of the Nineveh Plain have historical reasons to be fearful. Long before ISIS’s rise last year, extremist Sunnis have systematically killed, displaced, and threatened the Chaldo-Assyrian, Yazidi, and Shabak communities, labeling them crusaders, devil-worshipers, and infidels, Kurdish authorities, meanwhile, are pressuring the groups to support their drive to incorporate Ninevah into Kurdistan.

Bombings in Nineveh in August 2007 by suspected armed Islamists killed more than 300 Yazidis and wounded 700. In May of this year, suspected ISIS gunmen shot dead six Yazidi farmers in Nineveh, prompting thousands of other Yazidis to flee to Sanjar, a town west of Mosul, only to find themselves caught in fighting in recent days between Shia and ISIS fighters there.

In addition to fearing for their lives now, al-Hamdaniyah’s Chaldo-Assyrian Christians, who comprise 70 percent of the district’s population, also expressed broader concerns about their future, saying the current fighting may bring the longstanding Kurdish-Arab contest for control of Nineveh to a head.

Their fears were echoed by the Chaldean patriarch Louis Sako, the leader of Iraqi Christians.  He told me during my visit to Bakhdida that the situation for his flock was “critical.”

“As a minority we face a double threat," Sako said while visiting 35 displaced families from Mosul who were living in classrooms in the town’s theological center.

"The country will be divided, it is clear,” Sako said, referring to proposals to carve up Iraq into three separate political entities for Sunni, Shia, and Kurds. “Where does that leave the Christians?"

Post by:
Topics: Iraq

soundoff (11 Responses)
  1. Ferhat Balkan

    Indeed, the violence there will never end until people get equal treatment from their government. Apparently, Al-Maliki decided to help only the Shia Muslims and oppress the Sunni minority. And now, instead of offering change, he's engaging in war rhetoric. The only solution that I can see for Iraq at this point is division. 3 Separate states for Sunni, Shia and Kurds. No one wants a bloody civil war and going in and bombing civilians isn't going to help either.

    June 24, 2014 at 7:20 pm | Reply
    • Retired Military

      Ferhat: Well stated. The only concern I have in your scenario is ISIS owning the Sunni state. Not that you said that, but they are not going away without a full spectrum fight. This is going to be a serious life and death struggle for these 3 main groups, not to mention the minority groups mentioned in the posting. ISIS continues to consolidate its geographic gains, steal money, gold and oilfields. They are well financed. They are well led tactically and are savvy in terms of technology use and social media. I believe they will be regionally focused in establishing a "state/islamic caliphate" in the near term, but will in time be setting their sights on the West and "infidels". Maybe they will become pragmatic if they are forced to govern instead of beheading and the long list of other unconscionable atrocities they are currently committing. I think we all know that is wishful thinking. One only needs to look at organizations like Hamas or Islamic Jihad.

      June 24, 2014 at 11:08 pm | Reply
    • Joseph McCarthy

      Until Iraq is finally divided into three different states, there will be no true peace. As for the minorities, they could settle in Kurdistan where they stand a fairly good chance of finding peace since the Kurds tend to be more tolerant than do the Shiites or the Sunnis.

      June 25, 2014 at 12:05 am | Reply
      • Retired Military

        Joseph: as unfortunate as it is for these minorities to have to relocate, I think you are absolutely right. The alternative is most certainly death.

        June 25, 2014 at 12:23 am |
  2. Peter mabas

    Often times the poor and innocent ones are always the victims of the extreme wickedness of thier fellow beings, what a poor and helpless situation for the minorities who are inbetween the crossfire of the two sides GOD HELP THEM.

    June 25, 2014 at 5:27 am | Reply
  3. Joey Isotta-Fraschini@

    Were I a minority member in Iraq, my best goal would be relocation in another country.
    I knew wise, strong men and women who lived a long time in prosperity because they had the foresight to escape Germany or Russia before the rise of Hitler or Russian communism.

    June 25, 2014 at 12:40 pm | Reply
  4. Suliman

    UPDATE from family in al-Hamdaniyah: As of 25 June 2014, The Kurdish Peshmerga and ISIS are engaged in fighting in Bakhdida. Most of the Christians and other minorities in the area have fled to Kurdistan.

    June 25, 2014 at 1:37 pm | Reply
  5. j. von hettlingen

    Modern Iraq is in an area once home to some of the earliest civilisations. These religious and ethnic minorities in the region: Assyrian and Chaldean Christians, Turkmen, Shabaks, and predominantly Kurdish Yazidis etc had in the past submitted to Ottoman rule and military dictatorship after Iraq gained independence. It's sad to be a minority, which doesn't have the strength to opt for autonomy.

    June 26, 2014 at 11:23 am | Reply
    • Joey Isotta-Fraschini

      That is quite true, j. von hettlingen. Unfortunately, most people don't realize it. They entertain this stupid notion that "democracy" will "solve" everything.

      June 26, 2014 at 12:55 pm | Reply
      • Joey Isotta-Fraschini@

        @ My Troll,
        Actually, my suggestion would be a benign dictator. He would have the wisdom of Solomon, and corruption could not touch him.
        There being few candidates for that position, democracy is the second choice, and the best idea so far.

        June 26, 2014 at 1:21 pm |

Post a comment


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.