May 25th, 2011
01:33 AM ET

5 areas of Israeli-Palestinian disagreement

By Elise Labott, CNN's Senior State Department Producer

After Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gave his speech to Congress today, Foreign Policy’s Josh Rogin and I sat down for a conversation with Netanyahu’s spokesman, Mark Regev. He elaborated on the Prime Minister’s speech.

After talking to Regev, I interviewed Maen Areikat, the Chief Palestinian Representative to the United States.

There are five areas where the two sides are at odds, which could complicate efforts to forge a final peace deal: (1) borders and land swaps, (2) Hamas and recognition of Israel, (3) Jordan Valley, (4) Jerusalem and (5) consequences of the Arab Spring.

1. Borders and land swaps

For the first time Prime Minister Netanyahu publicly said that if the Israelis and Palestinians did reach a final peace deal, “some settlements will end up beyond Israel's borders.”

Israeli spokesman Mark Regev insists that Israel is expanding only in territories they expect to keep. We tried to press him whether Israel would would commit to not building in the areas it expects to give up as a sign of seriousness about negotiations, but he said that Israel will “play its cards in the process of negotiations" on all the core issues.

He added that Israel can’t agree on a final position of a border without certain “guarantees” from the Palestinians in negotiations that they won't be attacked from territory they are pulling out of.

Maen Areikat told us the settlements that Israel wants to keep as part of the land swaps are problematic. Additionally, he said, Israel’s desire to keep roads leading in and around the settlements for future expansion constitute a lot of land to be swapped, which could affect the character of the Palestinians state.

Hamas and recognition of Israel

In his speech, Netanyahu urged President Abbas to dissolve his Fatah party’s agreement with Hamas, saying that Israel could never negotiate with a Palestinian government that is backed by “the Palestinian version of al-Qaeda,” which refuses to accept Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state.

Netanyahu said if the Palestinians were to separate from Hamas, Israel would be prepared to talk about all issues, but until then "The ball is clearly in the Palestinian court." As Regev put it, Israel needs to hear its Jewish aspirations are legitimate.

As the Palestinians see it, they stay out of Israel’s domestic politics and Israel should not interfere with their internal politics. Arikat argued that Palestinians must be united in order for a negotiated settlement with Israel to have legs.

The agreement that the PLO made with Hamas, he said, paves the way for democratic elections where he expects Palestinians will vote for a peaceful resolution to the conflict with Israel.

Jordan Valley

Israel and the United States have called for a “non-militarized” Palestinian state - meaning the future state of Palestine would have no army. Furthermore, Netanyahu called for a continued Israel military presence in the Jordan Valley.

Regev cited many examples of sovereign states with foreign forces on their territory, such as Japan and Korea, both of which consented to the troops in treaties.

Arikat called troops in the Jordan Valley a non-starter that would give Israel a third of the West Bank, which he considers a major portion of a future Palestinian state. Additionally, he said, any designs Netanyahu has on controlling international crossing points, Palestinian airspace and water are an affront to Palestinian sovereignty and are therefore unacceptable.

Jerusalem

Prime Minister Netanyahu unequivocally stated that Jerusalem must remain the u capital of Israel, while the Palestinians have called for East Jerusalem to be the capital of a future Palestine. Several proposals have been floated for Jerusalem to have international status, but this still proves to be one of the thorniest issues of the peace process.

Arab spring

This week President Obama warned that rapid change in the Middle East might not work to Israel’s benefit if it didn’t move to make peace with the Palestinians.

Not only did Obama restate the fact that the number of Palestinians living in Israel is growing rapidly and threatening Israel’s Jewish identity, he warned that the new generation of Arabs reshaping the region will demand rights for the Palestinians as well. He suggested that longtime dictators like Hosni Mubarak are no longer around to guarantee the peace process.

Netanyahu acknowledged the “epic battle” against tyranny in the Middle East and said it “holds the promise of a new dawn of freedom and opportunity."

Josh Rogin and I tried to push Regev on the point that the new democratically elected leaders of the region may not be supportive a peace deal with Israel, but Regev insisted that Israel has nothing to fear from democracy in the Arab world.

Arikat said it was ironic that Netanyahu should talk about liberty and freedom without acknowledging that close to 4 million Palestinians are under occupation. The Arab world, he insisted, would not abandon the Palestinian cause and the region’s “winds of change” would ultimately affect the struggle of the Palestinians and help them achieve statehood.

That's a quick summary of my Tuesday interviews.  What do you think about Obama and Netanyahu's speeches and the core issues above?


soundoff (522 Responses)
  1. Robbie Divincenzo

    The apex stock to purchase for 2021 range with small-cap diamonds in the rough like URBT to dominant emerging stocks. When you have $1,000 available right now, the subsequent groundbreaking stock can be perfect for opportunistic long-term buyers. Urban Television Network Corp stock OTC: URBT. I needn't know about you, but when I think of innovation, streaming services stocks come to mind. Over the past decade, we certainly have witnessed extraordinary developments in streaming bitrates along with devices which have been developed to support those services. We have now seen foremost streaming services like HBO and Hulu grab market share, but this little recognized company Urban TV Network Corp. have launched tremendous internet streaming services URBTPlus Movies + Live TV. I imagine this corporation is going to corner the urban internet streaming markeplace. The stock market always has a few surprises in store, just like any shareholder in 2020 would corroborate. URBT has already been surprising with a 500 increase over 12 months. But by & large, the main element experts are looking at it as they discover the top stocks to obtain for 2021 is the same variable that dominated 2020: COVID-19. And streaming service URBTPlus is addressing the call. So as an trader have a look at Urban Televison Network Corporation. stock symbol URBT. #top5investment2121

    https://www.otcmarkets.com/stock/URBT/profile

    December 26, 2020 at 1:58 am |
  2. Gilberte Tantum

    Well I really enjoyed reading it. This article offered by you is very effective for correct planning.

    http://www.X7wFVYZgcs.com/X7wFVYZgcs

    December 26, 2020 at 2:45 am |
  3. Hosea Chinault

    I loved as much as you willyou'll receive carried out right here. The sketch is tastefulattractive, your authored subject mattermaterial stylish. nonetheless, you command get boughtgot an edginessnervousnessimpatienceshakiness over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come furthermore formerly again sinceas exactly the same nearly a lotvery often inside case you shield this increasehike.

    https://www.kongregate.com/accounts/Bestdrawing

    December 28, 2020 at 6:37 am |
  4. Marilyn

    Hi tһere! I know this is kinda off topic Ьut I was wondering ԝhich
    blog platform arе үօu usіng fⲟr this site?

    I'm gettіng fed up of WordPress becɑuse I've had issues
    witһ hackers and I'm looking at options for another platform.
    I would be fantastic if yoս cοuld point me in tһe
    direction of ɑ ցood platform.

    Ⅿy website :: pubic hair removal (Mauricio)

    December 30, 2020 at 1:04 am |
  5. Herman Can

    My spouse and IWeMy partner and I stumbled over here coming from afrom aby a different web pagewebsitepageweb address and thought I mightmay as wellmight as wellshould check things out. I like what I see so now i amnow i'mi am just following you. Look forward to going overexploringfinding out aboutlooking overchecking outlooking atlooking into your web page againyet againfor a second timerepeatedly.

    https://wanelo.co/bestwhitepccases

    December 31, 2020 at 2:49 am |
  6. Felipe Weidler

    hihello!,I loveI really likeI like your writing sovery so muchmucha lot! percentageproportionshare we keep in touchkeep up a correspondencecommunicatebe in contact moreextra approximatelyabout your postarticle on AOL? I needrequire an experta specialist in thison this spaceareahouse to solveto unravelto resolve my problem. May beMaybe that isthat's you! Taking a lookLookingHaving a look forwardahead to peerto seeto look you.

    https://www.sbnation.com/users/Phonescreenmagnifiers

    January 2, 2021 at 4:24 am |
  7. Emerald Nesbit

    Thanks for one'sfor onesfor yourfor your personalfor afor theon your marvelous posting! I actuallyseriouslyquitedefinitelyreallygenuinelytrulycertainly enjoyed reading it, you could beyou areyou can beyou might beyou'reyou will beyou may beyou happen to be a great author. I will make sure toensure that Ibe sure toalwaysmake certain tobe sure toremember to bookmark your blog and willand definitely willand will eventuallyand will oftenand may come back from now ondown the roadin the futurevery soonsomedaylater in lifeat some pointin the foreseeable futuresometime soonlater on. I want to encourage you to ultimatelythat youyourself toyou to definitelyyou toone toyou continue your great jobpostswritingwork, have a nice daymorningweekendholiday weekendafternoonevening!

    https://www.diigo.com/profile/phonescreen

    January 7, 2021 at 8:16 am |
  8. Ernest Sparaco

    SweetWonderful blog! I found it while browsingsurfing aroundsearching on Yahoo News. Do you have any tipssuggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! ThanksMany thanksAppreciate itCheersThank you

    https://www.sbnation.com/users/Bestledgaragelights

    January 11, 2021 at 5:14 am |
  9. Adriana

    Ӏ seriously love yoսr website.. Pleasant colors & theme. Ⅾid you develop this site ʏourself?
    Ⲣlease reply back as I'm planning t᧐ cгeate my own website and would like tօ learn wһere you got
    thiѕ fгom or exactly whɑt thе theme is calleԁ.
    Thɑnks!

    Μy site; why people buy – Juanita,

    January 13, 2021 at 5:27 am |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.