What we need to know about Syria
July 18th, 2012
10:16 AM ET

What we need to know about Syria

By Fareed Zakaria

The death of Syria's defense minister – in an apparent suicide bombing for which the Syrian rebels have claimed responsibility – is a sign that the rebellion is gaining strength and the Assad regime is cracking. I certainly hope so, but it's important for us to admit that we actually know very little about what is going on in Syria.

Naturally, our hearts are with the rebels and the Free Syrian Army, so when we hear reports about this bombing, we hope it is a sign of their growing reach and effectiveness. But we don't really know much about the circumstances. Is the use of suicide bombing, for example, a sign of the greater involvement of Islamic jihadis?

Similarly, when we hear about a massacre, such as reports last week surrounding events in Hama province, we naturally assume that it has been done by the Syrian military in the most brutal possible way.

And in most cases it’s true. But in some cases we really don’t know enough to be sure. In this most recent massacre, there’s some evidence that perhaps the Syrian government’s version of events was closer to reality than we had realized. But what that highlights to me is not that the Syrian government is less culpable – this is a government that has systematically and brutally used violence against men, women and children. Bashar al-Assad and his henchmen have the blood of innocents on their hands. So whether all the stories are completely accurate or whether some of them are exaggerated seems to me largely irrelevant from a moral point of view.

What is relevant is this: we don’t know much about the rebels. We don’t know, for example, how organized they are or whether they are bands of free floating groups. We don’t know what is their agenda or agendas. And we also, despite today’s reports, don’t really know how effective they are.

The rebels don’t control any part of Syria. In fact, as far as I can see, they don’t seem to have even been able to hold a town in Syria for more than a day. They can launch sporadic attacks – sometimes very effective ones such as the bombing yesterday – they can keep government forces on edge. But they haven’t been able to hold territory. Compare that with Libya, where the Libyan rebels were able to hold almost a third of the country and they took control of a major city, Benghazi.

Now Libya is a very different place – it’s much bigger, with more open spaces to hide in. But that’s precisely my point – for reasons of geography, perhaps, or maybe because of lack of organization, the Free Syrian Army hasn’t been able to succeed in some basic ways. Perhaps it’s because the Syrian military is very powerful and effective. Perhaps there are other, sectarian, explanations.

The first step toward figuring out what we can or should do – understanding the situation on the ground.

What we need to know are the following: is the opposition fighting together in a coordinated way? Who leads it? Does the Syrian National Council — the main exile opposition group – have any sway over these forces? Do the groups on the ground have any sectarian flavor? Are they largely Kurdish or Sunni? What is the role of the jihadi militant groups in the Syrian rebellion?

All this is not an argument for inaction – I’ve laid out a strategy to put intense pressure of the Assad regime earlier. But we need good information. And I’d say this applies not just to Western governments, but to the Western media as well.

Post by:
Topics: Media • Middle East • Syria

soundoff (336 Responses)
  1. ass9

    Those AKs are absolutely beautiful.

    December 6, 2012 at 7:06 pm |
  2. Ruya Geran

    I find your article biased and provocatif. While you claim not much is known even about the bombings in Syria, you give an open support to the rebels and almost send them a message from here that they should get more organised. For this alone, your blogs should be banned.

    You say " for reasons of geography, perhaps, or maybe because of lack of organization, the Free Syrian Army hasn’t been able to succeed in some basic ways. Perhaps it’s because the Syrian military is very powerful and effective. Perhaps there are other, sectarian, explanations"

    Guess what, perhaps the rebels dont have the majority support from the people of Syria! In fact there is a common belief that most of the rebels you portray as the freedom army is made up of the infiltrants from Iraq and Iran who are aiming yet for another Shiite state. Moreover, I am yet to see an interview with Syrian Joe Public and friends condemning the Asad regime!

    I have no connection to the Middle East, yet the political strategy for the region worries me to no end. Syrian chaos is rather timely when Israel is trying to put into effect new plans for Gaza. I wonder what would happen to Golan Heights if Syria falls. Larger Israel? Would the rise of Hamas in Syria justify/rationalise the raison d'etre of Israel and why the US should continue to inject money to its little brother?

    A pole requires another pole for equilibrium. Here a pole is being created to justify the other. What a shame that one of the last geographies of secularity is being forced to fall, people's but mainly women's freedom is jeopardised along with the country's infrastructure and prosperity. Look what a handful of what you call freedom fighters turned Iraq, Egypt and Libya into...a place of chaos, powerty and radical islam hence no freedom. What happened to the poor US ambassador in Libya should say something...perhaps the real people of these countries. vs the foreign mucahids, did support their regime. Who are you and I to tell them what is good for them, the real citizens.

    Now think again why Syria is not cracking....

    December 12, 2012 at 1:05 pm |
  3. toyota bandung

    At present automation makes a vital contribution to
    industrial manufacturing. If there are any mistakes during this brief examination, they will need
    to be set before the examination can continue.
    Etios Liva Diesel Price and Etios Diesel Price which are hopes to hold till last minutes of launch.

    May 30, 2015 at 8:02 pm |
  4. Romaine Russey

    I think your blog is getting more and more visitors.*;~::


    December 20, 2020 at 7:05 pm |
  5. Julian Edmons


    January 11, 2021 at 12:48 am |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.