The myth of an Arab Spring in Pakistan
January 30th, 2013
10:32 AM ET

The myth of an Arab Spring in Pakistan

By Michael Kugelman, Special to CNN

Editor’s note: Michael Kugelman is the senior program associate for South Asia at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington, DC. You can follow him @MichaelKugelman. The views expressed are his own.

Will Pakistan experience an Arab Spring? The question has been on many minds since revolution swept across the Middle East and North Africa in 2011 – and especially since a major anti-government rally took place in Islamabad this month.

It's easy to understand why. Pakistan, like the Arab Spring nations, boasts a young and mobile communications savvy population. Its masses are victims of the same indignities that incited revolt in the Middle East: corruption, oppression, and injustice.

However, the similarities end there. Let’s stop talking about a revolution in Pakistan, because it’s not going to happen.

It’s tempting to think Pakistan harbors revolutionary impulses. In recent weeks, a cleric named Tahir ul Qadri led a march to Pakistan’s capital that he vowed would culminate in the fall of the government. Tens of thousands – including women and children – camped out in Islamabad to cheer Qadri’s fiery anti-government speeches.

Yet this story yielded a decidedly counter-revolutionary denouement. Qadri stepped off the stage and entered into negotiations with government officials. The outcome? An “Islamabad Long March Declaration” calling for the government to be dissolved by mid-March, and for a caretaker government to take over until elections are held within 90 days of the government’s dissolution. This is actually the direction the government was moving in before the march – part of a constitutionally mandated transition process for election years, and 2013 is one such year.

More from GPS: Yes, it could get worse

In effect, the chief revolutionary signed a backroom deal with the state that left everything in place – and his supporters literally out in the cold. Not exactly a scene from Tahrir Square.

In Pakistan, power is about personalities, not people. Pakistanis frequently gravitate toward charismatic politicians who, messiah-like, vow to single-handedly rid the nation of its afflictions. Yet these leaders often come across as mere pawns of Pakistan’s established power brokers.

Take Qadri. He is known for his galvanizing anti-government rhetoric, but he also supported Pakistan’s military coup in 1999, and expresses pro-army views. Tellingly, the Long March Declaration stipulates that his political party help select a caretaker prime minister. This has all fueled speculation that his march was engineered by Pakistan’s powerful armed forces to deepen their behind-the-scenes influence over politics.

Meanwhile, Imran Khan, a former cricket star contesting this year’s elections, often resorts to crowd-pleasing populist rhetoric, such as vowing to end corruption in 90 days. Yet he has struggled to shake the perception that his campaign has been sponsored, if not bankrolled, by Pakistan’s security establishment.

Be this as it may, there’s no denying the extraordinary ability of these charismatic figures to mobilize the masses. Khan has drawn huge crowds – some estimate as many as 500,000 people – to his campaign rallies. Qadri attracted tens of thousands to his march even though he’s lived in Canada for the last seven years.

So imagine for a moment that a truly independent charismatic leader materializes, one with no strings to be pulled, and who genuinely desires to precipitate a people's revolution. Could such a figure’s prodigious mobilizing abilities launch a mass movement for change?

Don’t count on it.

Why? Because mobilization is only a first step toward launching a revolution. The other steps – identifying core objectives and strategies, and them implementing them through mass action – are non-starters in Pakistan because the nation is too riven by division. Ethnic, provincial, and sectarian tensions are rife, effectively negating any hopes for unifying around a common cause, much less a leader (Khan is a deeply polarizing figure). Sunni-Shia cleavages run deep, and fractures between Sunni Barelvis and Sunni Deobandis are sharp. These religion-based fissures should put to rest any talk of an eventual Iran-style Islamic revolution.

It’s not just Pakistan’s fractures that inhibit mass movements for change. Thanks to the power of patronage, many everyday Pakistanis are allergic to actions that threaten the status quo because this could imperil the influence of friends and other patrons who help them get by in Pakistan’s unmeritocratic society.

Some may argue that Pakistan doesn’t need an Arab Spring because it has already experienced something approximating one – a pro-democracy movement in 2007. Lawyers, journalists, and students launched a campaign against the draconian policies of President Pervez Musharraf, which led to his resignation the next year and to an era of democracy that has shakily endured to the present day.

Still, while that movement may have produced democracy, it has failed to overhaul the oppressive culture of corruption and impunity that continues to enrage the Pakistani masses today. Sadly, this culture is unlikely to be eliminated anytime soon.

As the Qadri march wrapped up, local media reported that poor hygiene conditions had sent more than 90 sickened participants to the hospital. Social media reports (albeit unconfirmed ones) claimed that several people had died.

What a tragic yet appropriate coda in a nation where people’s privations, not people power, carry the day.

Post by:
Topics: Pakistan

soundoff (158 Responses)
  1. American

    An Arab Spring isn't needed in Pakistan. What an Arab Spring means is that there is chaos for a while, many people die, and you end up with an Islamist government where women and other religions are second class citizens. You already have all that in Pakistan.

    February 3, 2013 at 9:52 pm |
  2. Vu

    That region is becoming the future Middle East. Pakistan and India can both make use of Arab Spring. It is up to younger generation. Change brings Change.

    As Mahatma Gandhi said, The spirit of democracy is not a mechanical thing to be adjusted by abolition of forms. It requires change of heart.

    February 3, 2013 at 10:10 pm |
  3. RealistMAN

    NUKE Pakistan! This is the only way to save Pakistani's from their state and the rest of the world as well. They should have named this illegitimate child of british empire as CancerSTAN or TerrorSTAN.

    February 4, 2013 at 2:04 pm |
  4. RealistMAN

    I don't buy the arguments about Pakistanis being part of human race and deserve respect etc. If any of you know of a Paki, be it in the west or middle east, you will find them the most insincere, two-faced, double dealer crooks. Wanna test? Call Paki real estate agent in your area and have him show you some properties. It will only take 2 minutes the massive trickery, dishonesty and fraud to come to display. Don't believe me, believe your own ears and eyes. Its free to try. Just befriend a paki!

    February 4, 2013 at 2:09 pm |
    • Pea Brain

      Man, such love. You got dealt a pretty bad hand, I presume? Also a tad bit racist I must say, don't you think?

      September 8, 2014 at 9:11 am |
  5. Jack X

    Its a failed state we just have to ensure it implodes instead of exploding that's all there is to it.

    February 4, 2013 at 8:45 pm |
  6. Rick McDaniel

    Ya know........that is simply stupid, wishful thinking.

    Pakistan will be a problem for America, as far into the future, as anyone can see.

    February 6, 2013 at 10:26 am |
  7. Catherine Woods

    Pakistan needs wake up call. Who is its enemy? India, the US or itself?
    The young Pakistanis should sit down and analyse their past not through the rose tinted glasses of anti-India, religious extremism and false victimization but objective rationality! It has been the director and producer of its own messes. Excessive military control, adherence to hollow feudal traditions, refusal to acknowledge its flaws and opportunistic policies have all been its tools in rupturing its development.
    Recognize past mistakes and rectify them for the future.

    February 7, 2013 at 1:10 am |
  8. Property Turkey

    Maximos real estatewill support you with our after sales services once you decide to buy a property through us. You will be able to contact us at any time for any issue related to your property that you will buy through us.

    We can make the interior of your property more refined with decorative products depending on the wishes of our clients. We make the house usable and liveable by means of stylish and high-quality furniture for every budget dealing with furniture and white goods stores, and designing the houses if needed by specialised engineers.

    Responsibility to maintain the property during the absence of its owner.
    Payment of all monthly real estate receivables from bills and dues.
    Leasing and investing in the property if it is desired.
    When the apartment owners want to sell their apartments, we deal directly with sales and marketing.

    October 10, 2019 at 4:43 am |
  9. Odis Belch

    nicotine can really make you an addict, stay away from cigarettes in the first place-

    December 20, 2020 at 5:38 pm |
  10. 안전카지노

    Best view i have ever seen !

    January 13, 2021 at 5:07 am |
1 2 3

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.