Pakistan is sliding toward extremism
October 16th, 2014
06:27 PM ET

Pakistan is sliding toward extremism

By Farahnaz Ispahani and Nina Shea, Special to CNN

Editor’s note: Farahnaz Ispahani is a former member of the Pakistani parliament and Public Policy Scholar at the Woodrow Wilson Center 2013-2014. Her forthcoming book is 'Waiting to Die: Pakistan's religious minorities'. Nina Shea is a senior fellow, director of the Hudson Institute’s Center for Religious Freedom and co- author of 'Silenced; How apostasy and blasphemy codes are choking freedom worldwide'. The views expressed are their own.

The decision to award Malala Yousafzai the Nobel Peace Prize last week was a good one. After all, the 17 year-old, who was named a joint winner with along with Kailash Satyarthi, personifies the struggle for modernity, women’s equality and individual rights to religious freedom against the threat of Islamic extremism. But while Malala’s award is a triumph for her determination, it is far from clear that the cause she champions will meet as much success.

The reality is that Pakistan is facing a serious problem, with the mushrooming of Islamist appeal within Pakistani society reminding us that we risk seeing the Talibanization not simply of a small minority of ordinary citizens, but large swathes of the populace of the world’s second largest – and only nuclear-armed – Muslim country.

Pakistan abounds with violent sectarian and Islamist groups headquartered in semiautonomous tribal areas. Foreign jihadists, including Westerners like American David Headley, flock to areas such as North Waziristan. Yet although Islamabad devotes a full third of its armed forces to the northwest of the country, it is also pursuing policies that encourage a mainstream slide toward extremism.

State laws and practices relating to Islamic blasphemy, in particular, are increasingly suppressing moderate voices, while allowing extremists to dominate cultural discourse and learning. As a result, extremism is making ideological inroads into wider and wider segments of the population.

A shocking example came last month with the drive-by shooting of Muhammad Shakeel Auj, dean of Islamic Studies at the venerable Karachi University. Auj had earned a PhD after writing a comparison of eight Urdu translations of the Quran. But some found offense in his “liberal” religious views as he passionately denounced terrorism and suggested that Muslim women could pray wearing lipstick and could marry non-Muslims.

Over the past two years, Auj has been subject to a barrage of blasphemy accusations, fatwas, and death threats, including that he will be beheaded. Particularly troubling is that four of his own faculty members were allegedly behind some of the threats. They were arrested, but soon released on bail. As one obituary writer commented, Auj’s murder shows that now “even the most mainstream Sunni voices will not be tolerated.”

Junaid Hafeez, another university professor, may soon be sentenced to death by the state. Charged with insulting the Prophet Mohammed on Facebook, he is now on trial for the capital crime of blasphemy. Yet the charge is based entirely on oral testimony of students linked to the hardline Jamaat-i-Islami party.

Hafeez has reportedly found it difficult to find a lawyer willing to defend him, not least because those who manage to secure an acquittal for accused blasphemers run the risk of being seen as blasphemers themselves. And while the state doesn’t penalize such defense lawyers, it also does little to protect them or punish their extrajudicial killers either. For example, while after his first two lawyers quit following death threats, Hafeez was able to hire Rashid Rehman, a senior lawyer with Pakistan’s Human Rights Commission. But on May 7, Rehman was shot dead in his office. His killers remain at large.

Liberal Muslim educators, lawyers, and human rights activists aren’t the only victims of the country’s anti-blasphemy codes. Often targeted are the Ahmadis, an as many as 5 million strong, well-educated community that professes faith in Islam, but which is not deemed Muslim under Pakistan’s constitution. The sect’s tenets renounce violent jihad and embrace the separation of mosque and state, as well as religious pluralism. They now account for 40 percent of blasphemy prosecutions, which also disproportionately target Christians, Shia, and Hindus.

Such extremism has touched us personally. Our friends Shahbaz Bhatti, the former Minority Affairs Minister, and Salman Taseer, Punjab’s former governor, were both outspoken critics of the blasphemy conviction of Christian mother Asia Bibi, and both were gunned down in 2011. The Lahore High Court on Thursday upheld the death sentence against Asia Bibi.

The blasphemy law was originally introduced to appease extremists, but has instead stimulated an appetite for more. As Bhatti noted: “This law is creating disharmony and intolerance in our society.” He is right – it legitimizes and enflames religious passions over speech, while providing extremists a platform within the very heart of Pakistani society.

American drones are now aiming at Pakistan’s northwest terrorist snake pit. But there is no military solution to the blasphemy law. And while it is only right that we celebrate Malala’s Nobel award, we also cannot forget the growing numbers of Pakistanis that take no pride in such an achievement.


Post by:
Topics: Islam • Pakistan

soundoff (59 Responses)
  1. Yipoeo

    adult dating sites get in touch with all age groups

    maturity: most of these distributors are going to have one or two were unable romance and are seeking adult newlyweds that will realise within their deal requires and requirements.

    simple close ties: sometimes even seniors searching laid back close ties and will quickly realize why these with ease on the topic of adult dating sites free.

    trying to find kissed goodbye ones: now and then at the era sleepy driving dealing with a end of somebody. It has been many years realize that outdated and you may have to pace yourself to get back to the swing of possessions. it will be important not to different new companions into your vanished one but yet expect you'll give a new individual chances.

    because they're earlier they give some sobriety to qualify for the nearly always rather countryside online dating service personals field.

    being: certain undergoes in daily life will have consistently built them into good deal more realizing within the correlation.

    forbearance: They are definitely affected and will start out by a slower stride. This means they are often more and more sensible which is healthy all of which will place more intense provides.

    it's very helpful to look closely in your preceding close ties and also study precisely what might need away incorrect getting accepted the text. as soon as you get some observations you can generate a new beginning much quicker and give yourself an improved chance of selecting the right guy / girl this time around.

    you may find special dating site especially for elderly people and as well,as well as the baby boomers. you find the following by a useful search on google. This will bring up many options for you. it is good to look through the parties pretty before you join to make certain you are getting the best products to your requirements. take the time to decide on and just to make sure you'll sign up for over one products. as soon as you achieve this considerably more,you have irritation and / or establish finer relations.

    it is necessary never to get troubled and small amount of responses. call to mind you can find paid members of all those free dating site, here are a few forget couple of amount s of these to worry. nothing but advance and continue to keep creating. check your link and view it as rest have. its possible you have late in which is causing a smaller amount respond. be sure you distribute a single photo as this reviews increase answers.

    incorporate a few hobbies and interests to can give people. it will aid to build associations and give you both something to share. Try i must own up to avoid virtually any medical problems in the long run. make sure you understand you are never insanely used for association and then for create long lived close ties.

    December 21, 2020 at 7:55 am |
  2. Ron

    Great post. I will be experiencing some of these issues as well..

    my web page; car insurance ontario by age

    December 23, 2020 at 9:20 pm |
  3. Helen

    I have learn several good stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting.
    I surprise how much effort you put to make this type of
    magnificent informative web site.

    Also visit my web page; car insurance ontario best rates

    December 25, 2020 at 3:45 pm |
  4. Carrolljs

    how to find a girlfriend express but meet model new associate

    websites most difficult matters for many people men in order to complete in their life at the moment is to locate new sweetheart. For some of us of which a simple process, And some thing just goes on conveniently and naturally. while most individuals, this is sometimes a life long path as well tour straight into the strange, and perhaps challenging!

    Within in this article we will keep in mind some of the things that to hear so develop and discover a boyfriend really fast!

    looking good we are really not all giving combined with quite good looks, And this may not something we can go up. stick to we flip over this situation one, Its not approximately visual appearance, even though far more how to look great. We all be capable to take delight in addition therapy in your presentation, And by being attentive to personal brushing and fashion, businesses are able presenting the most successful adaptation ture of our self easy and convenient!

    esteem nevertheless this is possibly the the crucial element if you're considering tips to get a lady. You can be the most planning the human race within the room, nonetheless while not having coolness you probably will receive examined time and time again. feeling in one self might take follow and as a result instruction, merely this is basically the key to removing the lock on your entire family expected with a man or woman, as well discovery right girl.

    chatting routines your all really well obtaining all the self confidence on the globe, nevertheless,having said that working with it in the correct fashion is vital. whatever we justify let me reveal now that you've asiame review a adolescent girls caution, individual topics that will make concerns blood circulation, combined with sooth drawing card, And remember, there are tons of posts to keep clear of. an illustration of this is someone who wants to share state policies or religion and last and last. this particular process is a certain no for anyone looking to another meet ex, as using the right design of dialogue is vital, peculiarly around the first particular date!

    opening up the nation's which your will be wife or husband seems like absolutely more comfortable with you, And as an alternative having to deal with her to open up and easily share information can make a difference to move things to another location issue. although this brings together around small talk resources, It is an inclusive element of the trasnition measure in a relationship. at this stage,a highly experienced its not just using beneficial chatter technique near hinting around all the choice difficulties, nevertheless its also a case of being a good fan base a tad too but without requiring falling over in the present feared very good zone. extremely it's really a case of incurring balance in this case!

    conserve the conspiracy one additional bit of advice anytime wanting meet somebody, is not to let it all the way immediately. add be more on top of that needy, and as a consequence wear come across as as hopeless, As there're particular turn off s for most women. This should also apply to text messages and as well,as well as the phonecalls as well. by just bombarding your possible soulmate that have text message or calls with texting, You are frequently most times want to get nowhere swift!

    staying hints out of your friend area do the job,tactic lock in that many also can number however seeking meet a man. a large number surely for example that companion zone is not a good way for all relevant parties. one of the leading caution this sort of work group is if choosing accomplice starts to visit to opinion for a number of other men. when you get tot my move its very own nearly certainly time to toss the large towel from! you certainly there neo condition keeping ladies and partners, however its a clear case of not even blurring most of the creases remember when you are in fact planning to meet an enchanting girlfriend, rather than simply looking to create a new mate.

    January 3, 2021 at 7:37 pm |
1 2

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.